Practical Advice from Your Doctor: Before You Choose Next Year’s Health Plan
By Robyn A. Giard, ND
Open enrollment season is stressful, confusing and certainly requires a spreadsheet. You are tasked to review premiums, deductibles, copays, coinsurance, formularies and out-of-pocket maximums and it is tempting to choose whichever plan takes the least from your paycheck each month. But, and more often that not, the lowest premium is not always the lowest-cost choice. What you really need to know is: How well does this plan fit the health care my family and I are most likely to use?
1. Start with the clinicians and facilities you want to keep
Before comparing anything else, check whether your primary-care clinician, specialists, therapist, preferred hospital, laboratory and pharmacy participate with the specific plan—not merely the insurance company.
An insurer may offer several plans with different networks. A clinician who participates with one plan may not participate with another bearing the same company name.
Search the plan directory, but also confirm directly with the clinician’s office and the insurer. Provider directories can be incomplete or out of date. Ask about the exact plan name and network, and save a screenshot or written confirmation when possible.
Good news for Starry Brook patients—and those considering care with us: Beginning January 1, 2027, New Hampshire-regulated group health plans must cover eligible services provided by a licensed naturopathic doctor when the plan covers the same service from another qualified healthcare provider. Coverage still depends on your specific plan, network, deductible and benefits.

2. Look at the entire year, not only the monthly premium
Compare:
The annual premium
The deductible
Primary-care and specialist copays
Coinsurance after the deductible
Prescription costs
Laboratory and imaging costs
The individual and family out-of-pocket maximums
Whether out-of-network care is covered at all
A lower-premium plan can work well for someone who uses little care and could comfortably absorb an unexpected bill. If you regularly attend appointments, take medication, need laboratory monitoring or anticipate surgery, pregnancy, therapy or another significant health need, a higher-premium plan with better cost-sharing may cost less overall.
Run at least two scenarios: a fairly healthy year and a difficult year. Could you manage the deductible or out-of-pocket maximum if January became unexpectedly expensive?
3. Check every regular prescription
Do not assume a medication will remain covered simply because you stayed with the same insurance company. Plans can have different formularies, preferred drugs, tiers, quantity limits, step-therapy requirements and prior-authorization rules.
Check:
Whether each medication is on the new plan’s formulary
Its tier and estimated cost
Whether prior authorization or step therapy is required
Whether your pharmacy is preferred
Whether mail order is required for maintenance medication
Whether the plan excludes compounded medication or weight-management medication
This is particularly important for stimulants, hormone therapy, GLP-1 medications, brand-name drugs and medications for which you have already tried alternatives.
4. Do not confuse an HSA with an FSA
This distinction can save you from unnecessary December spending.
HSA funds generally roll over from year to year. The account belongs to you, and unused money can remain available for future qualified medical expenses. You ordinarily do not need to empty an HSA at year-end.

FSA funds may be subject to a use-it-or-lose-it rule. Some employers offer a limited carryover or a grace period, but the rules and deadlines are set by the plan. Ask your benefits department:
What is my final date to incur an eligible expense?
What is my final date to submit a claim?
Does the plan offer a carryover or grace period?
How much, if any, can carry forward?
Do not wait until the last week of December to discover that an appointment, product or service is not eligible.
5. Use remaining FSA money thoughtfully
Depending on your plan and medical needs, eligible expenses may include copays and deductibles, prescription medication, dental care, eye examinations, prescription glasses or contacts, hearing care, certain over-the-counter medications, menstrual-care products and other qualified expenses.
Eligibility is not determined by whether a product feels “health related.” Confirm questionable purchases with your plan administrator and retain itemized receipts. Supplements, wellness services and cosmetic treatments are not automatically eligible; some expenses require documentation of a specific medical condition.
6. Decide how much you can realistically contribute next year
If you elect an HSA-eligible health plan, consider whether you can contribute regularly—even if you cannot fund the annual maximum. A modest automatic contribution can create a cushion for prescriptions, deductibles and unexpected care.
For an FSA, review what you actually spent this year rather than selecting a hopeful round number. Include predictable prescriptions, copays, dental work, vision expenses and planned procedures, but remember that unused funds may be forfeited under your plan’s rules.
7. Save the evidence
Keep the plan summary, formulary results, network confirmations, prior-authorization approvals and benefits correspondence. When coverage questions arise later, having the exact document you relied upon is far more useful than remembering that someone said it “should be covered.”
A five-minute election checklist
Before clicking Submit, ask:
Are my clinicians, hospital, laboratory and pharmacy in network?
Are my medications covered, and at what tier?
What must I pay before office visits, labs or prescriptions are covered?
What is the worst-case annual out-of-pocket cost?
Can I afford that amount if a difficult medical year begins in January?
Am I enrolling in an HSA or FSA, and do I understand its rules?
Have I checked my current FSA balance and claim deadline?
Health insurance cannot eliminate every unpleasant surprise. A careful review now, however, can prevent an inexpensive-looking plan from becoming a very expensive mismatch.
If you are an established Starry Brook patient and need information about our participation with a plan, contact the office before making your election. We can confirm our own contracting status, but only the insurer can provide a binding determination of your benefits, network and coverage.
This article provides general educational information and is not tax, legal or insurance advice. Plan documents and the insurer or plan administrator control coverage and eligibility decisions.





Comments